In the rapidly evolving world of IoT, knowing exactly where your devices are located remains a fundamental requirement for many organizations. While GPS has traditionally been the go-to technology for location tracking, there are scenarios where alternative or complementary approaches like cellular and WiFi triangulation offer advantages. Let’s explore how these different location technologies can work on their own or together to deliver the optimal solution for tracking your assets.
Understanding Location Technologies for IoT
When it comes to knowing “where in the world” your devices are, manufacturers aren’t settling for just one answer to the question. Here are three options for determining device location:
- GPS/GNSS: Provides global coverage with high accuracy in outdoor environments
- Cell Tower Triangulation: Works by measuring signals from multiple cellular towers
- WiFi Triangulation: Uses nearby WiFi access points to calculate position
Each approach has distinct advantages and limitations that make them better suited for different use cases and environments.
GPS/GNSS: Global Satellite Positioning
GPS (Global Positioning System) and other GNSS (Global Navigation Satellite Systems) determine location by measuring the time it takes for signals to travel from multiple satellites to the receiver:
- The device receives signals from four or more orbiting satellites
- Each satellite transmits its precise location and the exact time the signal was sent
- The receiver calculates the distance to each satellite based on signal travel time
- The device’s position is determined by triangulating these distances
This approach provides global coverage and works without relying on local infrastructure, making it ideal for outdoor tracking applications, despite limitations requiring line of site to satellites.
The pros of GPS tracking:
|
The cons of GPS tracking:
|
Cell Tower Triangulation: Leveraging Cellular Networks
Cell tower triangulation uses data from multiple cellular towers to pinpoint a device’s location:
- The device connects to or detects signals from nearby cell towers
- Signal strength and tower location data are collected
- Algorithms process this information to calculate the device’s position
- The estimated location is derived from the intersection points of coverage areas
While a single tower connection can provide rough location data that can be accurate within several hundred meters, connecting to multiple towers significantly improves accuracy, offering the potential to estimate device location within tens of meters.
The pros of cellular triangulation:
|
The Cons of cellular triangulation:
|
WiFi Triangulation: Precision for Indoor Environments
WiFi triangulation is similar to cell tower triangulation but works by leveraging WiFi access points:
- The device scans for nearby WiFi access points
- Information about visible access points (SSID, MAC address, signal strength) is collected
- This data is cross-referenced against databases of known WiFi locations
- A precise location estimate is calculated based on this information
WiFi triangulation often delivers superior accuracy in urban and indoor environments and can easily achieve accuracy within a few meters. This makes it particularly valuable for indoor asset tracking.
The pros of WiFi triangulation:
|
The cons of WiFi triangulation:
|
The Business Value of Multi-Technology Asset Tracking
Why settle for just one tracking technology? Modern IoT deployments benefit from having multiple location-determining technologies available. Implementing a flexible location tracking approach offers several advantages:
- Improved Reliability – By combining multiple location technologies, devices can be located from open outdoor spaces to building interiors and urban canyons, ensuring continuous visibility.
- Optimized Power Management – Different location technologies can be selected based on power availability and accuracy requirements:
- GPS for high-precision outdoor tracking when power is available
- WiFi triangulation for indoor tracking with minimal power consumption
- Cell tower triangulation as a reliable backup when other methods aren’t available
- Extended Device Lifespan – Selecting location technology based on environment and power constraints can significantly extend battery life and reducing maintenance costs.
Blues Notecard: Simplifying Location Tracking
Blues Notecard is designed to make wireless connectivity for embedded devices as simple as plug-and-play. Cellular Notecards come with GPS tracking as standard and, depending on which connectivity solution you choose for your device, offers a combination of triangulation technologies.
Notecard Cell+WiFi gives you a seamless way to do all three, GPS tracking, WiFi triangulation, and cell-tower triangulation, in a highly customizable way. And Notecard’s backing cloud service, Notehub, intelligently selects the “best” location from all available options; making it easy to keep track of where your devices are at all times. Whether your assets move through dense urban centers or remote areas with spotty coverage, this hybrid technology ensures continuous location visibility across all deployment scenarios.
Real-World Location Tracking Applications
Wondering how you could use location tracking to enhance your operation? Here are a few of the ways you could utilize Notecards’ built-in features:
Supply Chain & Logistics
Track shipments through warehouses, distribution centers, and retail locations where GPS signals are unavailable. With triangulation, companies gain end-to-end visibility into their supply chains, including indoor locations traditionally considered “blind spots.”
Industrial Equipment Monitoring
Monitor the location and usage of valuable equipment inside factories and warehouses without installing dedicated positioning infrastructure. The low-power requirements make tracking assets for years without battery replacement possible.
Smart Cities & Urban Monitoring
Deploy sensors throughout urban environments to monitor air quality, noise levels, traffic patterns, and more, all with precise location data even in challenging signal environments between tall buildings.
Healthcare Asset Management
Track critical medical equipment throughout healthcare facilities, ensuring that life-saving devices can be quickly located while reducing equipment loss.
The future of Location Tracking
As IoT deployments expand into increasingly challenging environments, having multiple location technologies available ensures continuous device visibility across all scenarios. By leveraging GPS, cellular, and WiFi triangulation as complementary technologies, solutions like the Blues Notecard enable comprehensive asset tracking with optimal power consumption and accuracy for each environment.
Whether you’re tracking assets through supply chains, monitoring equipment in industrial facilities, or deploying smart city sensors, the flexibility to choose the right location technology for each situation provides the reliability and accuracy your IoT applications demand, in any environment.
Are you ready to implement intelligent location tracking in your IoT solution? Notecard offers a plug-and-play approach that simplifies development while providing the security, reliability, and power efficiency required for real-world IoT deployments. Get in touch to hear more.
Additional Resources
- Get started with a Cell+WiFi Dev Kit
- Download the guide to learn more about industrial equipment monitoring
- Try an example app for continuous asset tracking